All draft pages

Returns and refunds

Draft for review, not in effect. Bracketed text like [support email] still needs filling in. This is not legal advice; the Terms and Privacy Policy should be checked by a lawyer before launch.

Decisions for you

  1. Store return policies: what can a Store choose? As written: no returns, or returns within 14 or 30 days, and who pays return shipping. One policy for the whole Store (as written) or per listing?
  2. Should sealed products ever be returnable for change of mind, even from a Store?
  3. Restocking fees: may Stores charge one (some card shops charge 10–15%) or banned (as written)?

Two kinds of returns

  • Something’s wrong: the package was lost, the item arrived damaged, it’s not the item you ordered, or it’s in a different condition than listed. You can always make a claim, from any seller, whatever their return policy. It’s covered by Buyer Protection, and the seller pays return shipping.
  • You changed your mind: only from a Store whose return policy accepts returns.

Regular sellers

Regular (free) accounts don’t take change-of-mind returns and can’t set a return policy. Buyers are still covered: if the package is lost or damaged, or the item isn’t correct or is in a different condition, make a claim from your order.

Stores: their own return policy

  • Each Store sets and edits its own return policy: no returns, or returns within 14 or 30 days. It is shown on every listing and on the Store page before you buy.
  • A change to the policy applies to orders placed after the change, not ones already made.
  • Request the return from your order within the Store’s return window.
  • You pay return shipping, with tracking, unless the Store’s policy says it pays.
  • The item must come back exactly as sent: graded slabs uncracked, sealed products unopened, raw cards in the same sleeve and top loader.
  • Sellers may not charge restocking fees.

Refunds

  • The seller has 3 business days after the return is delivered to inspect it. If they don’t respond, we refund you.
  • Refunds go back to your original payment method and usually appear within 5–10 business days.
  • For change-of-mind returns, the original shipping you paid is refunded only if the Store’s policy says so.
  • If a returned item comes back in a different condition, the seller can open a case and we decide based on photos from both of you.

Cancelling an order

You can ask the seller to cancel before it ships. If the seller hasn’t shipped within 5 business days of payment you can cancel for a full refund. Auction wins can’t be cancelled once you’ve paid unless the seller agrees.

Feedback