Returns and refunds
Draft for review, not in effect. Bracketed text like [support email] still needs filling in. This is not legal advice; the Terms and Privacy Policy should be checked by a lawyer before launch.
Decisions for you
- Store return policies: what can a Store choose? As written: no returns, or returns within 14 or 30 days, and who pays return shipping. One policy for the whole Store (as written) or per listing?
- Should sealed products ever be returnable for change of mind, even from a Store?
- Restocking fees: may Stores charge one (some card shops charge 10–15%) or banned (as written)?
Two kinds of returns
- Something’s wrong: the package was lost, the item arrived damaged, it’s not the item you ordered, or it’s in a different condition than listed. You can always make a claim, from any seller, whatever their return policy. It’s covered by Buyer Protection, and the seller pays return shipping.
- You changed your mind: only from a Store whose return policy accepts returns.
Regular sellers
Regular (free) accounts don’t take change-of-mind returns and can’t set a return policy. Buyers are still covered: if the package is lost or damaged, or the item isn’t correct or is in a different condition, make a claim from your order.
Stores: their own return policy
- Each Store sets and edits its own return policy: no returns, or returns within 14 or 30 days. It is shown on every listing and on the Store page before you buy.
- A change to the policy applies to orders placed after the change, not ones already made.
- Request the return from your order within the Store’s return window.
- You pay return shipping, with tracking, unless the Store’s policy says it pays.
- The item must come back exactly as sent: graded slabs uncracked, sealed products unopened, raw cards in the same sleeve and top loader.
- Sellers may not charge restocking fees.
Refunds
- The seller has 3 business days after the return is delivered to inspect it. If they don’t respond, we refund you.
- Refunds go back to your original payment method and usually appear within 5–10 business days.
- For change-of-mind returns, the original shipping you paid is refunded only if the Store’s policy says so.
- If a returned item comes back in a different condition, the seller can open a case and we decide based on photos from both of you.
Cancelling an order
You can ask the seller to cancel before it ships. If the seller hasn’t shipped within 5 business days of payment you can cancel for a full refund. Auction wins can’t be cancelled once you’ve paid unless the seller agrees.